AI Insights
What is human-in-the-loop in AI?
Quick links
A minimalist art deco aesthetic image of a circuit board in a continuous loop, representing human-in-the-loop AI. The loop integrates a stylized hand, heart, and brain along its path, symbolizing human interaction, emotion, and cognition influencing AI systems. The circuit board is sleek, glowing, and geometric, with smooth interconnected pathways. Clean, futuristic design with glowing accents in an art deco style—by Talbot West

What is human-in-the-loop in AI?

By Jacob Andra / Published September 30, 2024 
Last Updated: September 30, 2024

Human-in-the-loop introduces strategic human oversight into artificial intelligence workflows to mitigate hallucination and other errors.

Main takeaways
Human oversight improves AI accuracy and reduces errors.
Human-AI collaboration combines the strengths of both for optimal results.
Human input aligns AI systems with ethical standards and organizational values.
Human-in-the-loop approaches build trust and acceptance of AI technologies.

A brief explanation of HITL

In a human-in-the-loop (HITL) system, artificial intelligence (AI) handles the heavy lifting of data processing and initial analysis, while human intelligence provides oversight, makes decisions, and offers contextual understanding that machines can't quite grasp.

Here's how it typically works:

  1. The AI system processes data and generates initial results or recommendations.
  2. Human experts review these outputs, providing feedback or making final decisions.
  3. In some instances, the AI learns from this human input (fine-tuning the model).

HITL allows humans to perform critical quality control functions within an AI workflow and improves domain-specific knowledge of the generative AI system.

Why businesses should keep humans in the loop

Poor decision-making, inflexibility, and bias can cost businesses a lot of money. In high-risk industries such as healthcare or finance, the wrong choice could cost a life or end in a lawsuit.

The human-in-the-loop approach unleashes the power of AI while keeping it in the dog park. Human agents retain decision-making opportunities, tweak and finetune data, and guide AI through ambiguous or edge-case scenarios.

What are the advantages of human-in-the-loop AI?

Collaboration between humans and AI offsets the downsides of fully automated systems and creates a synergy that realizes the benefits of human and machine intelligence. Here’s why enterprises opt for HITL AI systems:

  • Improved accuracy: Human supervision catches and corrects AI errors.
  • Contextual understanding: People provide nuanced interpretations AI might miss.
  • Ethical oversight: Humans align AI decisions with ethical and societal values.
  • Adaptability: Knowledgeable humans help the AI navigate unforeseen scenarios.
  • Trust and accountability: Human decision-makers increase stakeholder confidence.
  • Continuous feedback loop: Human feedback helps intelligent systems grow through active learning.
  • Complex problem-solving: Combines AI's data processing with human creativity and intuition.
  • Reduced bias: Human reviewers can identify and mitigate AI biases.
  • Compliance: Easier to meet regulatory requirements in sensitive industries.
  • Workforce integration: Augments rather than replaces human workers.

HITL systems come in many shapes and sizes to meet organizational needs.

What does a HITL AI system look like?

HITL AI systems are made of multiple subsystems (AI and human) that coordinate to get things done right.

AI model

This is the engine of the system. It processes data, recognizes patterns, and generates initial outputs. Depending on your needs, this could be anything from a machine learning model for data classification to a natural language processing system for content analysis.

The human factor

These are the skilled professionals who interact with the AI system. They might be data scientists, subject matter experts, or trained operators. They review AI outputs, make decisions, and provide feedback that improves the system's performance over time.

AI-human interface

This is where the rubber meets the road in HITL systems. A well-designed interface facilitates human-AI collaboration. Interfaces need to be intuitive for human agents and guide them through prompting AI for best results.

Task allocation and feedback system

This component determines which tasks are handled by the AI and which require human intervention. It also defines how human feedback is processed by AI. This could include requests for data annotation and labeling, confidence threshold flags, or choices that always require human authorization.

Quality assurance protocols

These are the checks and balances that help the HITL system perform as intended. They include regular audits of AI outputs, assessments of human operator performance, and overall system effectiveness evaluations.

HITL AI applications

A human figure stands in the center, surrounded by a circular arrangement of industry symbols—gears, medical symbols, and digital graphs—connected by elegant flowing lines that suggest AI-powered networks. The AI elements glow softly, while the human figure gestures toward them in a guiding manner, showing partnership between humans and AI across industries—by Talbot West

Human-in-the-loop AI isn't just a theoretical concept—it's already transforming operations across various industries.

Enhanced medical diagnosis in healthcare

In healthcare, radiology departments use HITL AI to analyze medical images for potential abnormalities. Here's how it works:

  1. The AI system scans X-rays, MRIs, or CT scans, flagging areas of concern.
  2. Radiologists review these flagged areas, confirming or rejecting the AI's findings.
  3. The system learns from the radiologists' input, improving its accuracy over time.

Faster diagnoses and reduced human error risk allow radiologists to focus on more complex cases and offload gentler work to AI.

Fortifying fraud detection in finance

Financial institutions use HITL AI systems to combat increasingly sophisticated fraud attempts. The process typically unfolds like this:

  1. AI algorithms continuously monitor transactions for suspicious patterns.
  2. When potential fraud is detected, the case is escalated to human analysts.
  3. Analysts determine if it's genuine fraud or a false positive.
  4. Their decisions feed back into the AI to refine its fraud detection capabilities.

HITL allows financial institutions to cast a much wider fraud-prevention net without the overhead of additional personnel.

Perfecting quality control manufacturing

HITL systems allow manufacturers to drastically improve quality control. Here's a typical workflow:

  1. AI-vision systems inspect products on the assembly line.
  2. The AI flags potential defects or quality issues.
  3. Human quality control experts review flagged items, confirming defects or clearing products.
  4. The AI learns from these expert decisions, continually improving its defect detection accuracy.

This system allows for 100% inspection of products while allowing quality control personnel to dedicate more time to troubleshooting systemic product issues.

Elevating support experiences in customer service

HITL AI chatbots and virtual assistants improve customer interaction volume and quality. The process often works like this:

  1. AI chatbots handle initial customer inquiries, resolving simple issues automatically.
  2. For complex issues or when the AI is unsure, the conversation is handed off to a human agent.
  3. The human agent resolves the issue, and their solution is fed back into the AI system.
  4. Over time, the AI learns to handle more complex queries, freeing up human agents for the most challenging cases.

This approach provides fast, 24/7 customer support while retaining the nuanced attention only humans can provide.

These are just a fraction of the HITL use cases. Forward-thinking enterprises understand the value of AI integration and the importance of keeping humans in the loop.

What are the best practices for keeping humans in the loop of AI-driven processes?

HITL systems work best when they are thoughtfully implemented. Organizations should follow these best practices for a smooth, functional HITL AI implementation:

  • Establish specific responsibilities for human operators.
  • Design user-friendly dashboards for efficient human-AI interaction.
  • Invest in operator training so they understand the role of humans in HITL systems.
  • Establish clear protocols for handling ethical dilemmas.
  • Use human feedback to refine and enhance the AI system.
  • Foster communication between AI developers and end-users.

HITL implementation can be a juggling act. Whether you’re adding AI to your organization or modifying AI to add humans to the loop, expert guidance can make sure you’re not grasping at falling pins.

Implementing HITL AI in your organization

At Talbot West, we guide companies through the AI implementation process. We help with:

  • AI feasibility: We run a study to determine how feasible and useful HITL systems will be for your business.
  • AI proof of concept: We’ll do a limited pilot project to demonstrate that the system works and can generate a positive ROI.
  • AI strategy: We develop a cohesive HITL strategy so you have a blueprint to guide you through implementation and usage.
  • AI tool selection: We help you select the right tools and interfaces for your AI system.
  • AI implementation: We help you set up the framework, preprocess data, and calibrate your HITL tools.
  • AI ethics and governance: We verify that your HITL AI tools and usage patterns are legal, ethical, and effective.

Our mission is to blend your team's expertise and AI's capabilities, empowering your workforce and unleashing your organization’s potential.

Ready to explore an AI system with HITL for your organization?

Work with Talbot West

AI FAQ

AI performs many tasks across American enterprise and government sectors. It excels at:

  • Processing and analyzing vast amounts of data quickly
  • Recognizing patterns and making predictions
  • Automating repetitive tasks
  • Providing personalized recommendations
  • Enhancing image and speech recognition
  • Optimizing complex systems and processes
  • Assisting in decision-making through data-driven insights
  • Powering virtual assistants and chatbots
  • Enabling autonomous vehicles and robotics
  • Improving cybersecurity through threat detection

AI's capabilities continue to expand, but it still requires human oversight (HITL) for complex decision-making, ethical considerations, and handling novel situations.

A prominent example of a human-in-the-loop weapon is the Aegis Combat System used by the U.S. Navy. This advanced system integrates radar, missile launchers, and other weapons systems. While it can automatically detect, track, and provide firing solutions for threats, human operators make the final decision to engage targets. Human supervision and decision-making are required for AI defense systems that can execute lethal force.

One example of human-out-of-the-loop AI is the stock trading algorithms used in high-frequency trading. These AI systems:

  1. Analyze market data in real-time
  2. Identify trading opportunities based on predefined strategies
  3. Execute trades automatically, often in milliseconds
  4. Adjust strategies based on market conditions

These machine-learning algorithms make decisions and execute trades faster than any human could, operating independently once deployed. While humans set initial parameters and monitor overall performance, the moment-to-moment trading decisions are made by AI without human input or oversight.

Human-in-the-loop control theory is an approach to system design that integrates human decision-making into automated processes. It recognizes that in complex systems, human judgment enhances overall performance. HITL systems include:

  • Shared control between humans and automation
  • Real-time interaction and feedback mechanisms
  • Adaptive machine learning process that adjusts based on human input
  • Balancing cognitive workload between human and machine

This theory is applied in fields such as robotics, aviation, and process control. It aims to leverage the strengths of both human intelligence (creativity, adaptability, contextual understanding) and machine capabilities (speed, consistency, data processing) to create more robust and flexible systems.

About the author

Jacob Andra is the founder of Talbot West and a co-founder of The Institute for Cognitive Hive AI, a not-for-profit organization dedicated to promoting Cognitive Hive AI (CHAI) as a superior architecture to monolithic AI models. Jacob serves on the board of 47G, a Utah-based public-private aerospace and defense consortium. He spends his time pushing the limits of what AI can accomplish, especially in high-stakes use cases. Jacob also writes and publishes extensively on the intersection of AI, enterprise, economics, and policy, covering topics such as explainability, responsible AI, gray zone warfare, and more.
Jacob Andra

Industry insights

We stay up to speed in the world of AI so you don’t have to.
View All

Subscribe to our newsletter

Cutting-edge insights from in-the-trenches AI practicioners
Subscription Form

About us

Talbot West bridges the gap between AI developers and the average executive who's swamped by the rapidity of change. You don't need to be up to speed with RAG, know how to write an AI corporate governance framework, or be able to explain transformer architecture. That's what Talbot West is for. 

magnifiercrosschevron-downchevron-leftchevron-rightarrow-right linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram